• About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
Real Hardware Reviews
RHR
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Accessories
    • Processors (CPU)
    • GPU
    • Mobile
    • Games & Software
    • Systems
    • Cases
    • Tablet & Laptops
    • Ram
    • Storage
    • Motherboards
  • News
  • Off Topic
    • How To
    • Cryptocurrencies
No Result
View All Result
Real Hardware Reviews
RHR
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Accessories
    • Processors (CPU)
    • GPU
    • Mobile
    • Games & Software
    • Systems
    • Cases
    • Tablet & Laptops
    • Ram
    • Storage
    • Motherboards
  • News
  • Off Topic
    • How To
    • Cryptocurrencies
No Result
View All Result
Real Hardware Reviews
RHR
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home GPU

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review

Older but now even a better value

GaK_45 by GaK_45
May 30, 2019
in GPU, Recent, Reviews
XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
ADVERTISEMENT
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS XXX Edition 1386MHz OC+, 8GB GDDR5, VR Ready, Dual BIOS, 3xDP HDMI DVI, AMD...
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS XXX Edition 1386MHz OC+, 8GB GDDR5, VR Ready, Dual BIOS, 3xDP HDMI DVI, AMD Graphics Card (RX-580P8DFD6) (Renewed)
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS XXX Edition 1386MHz OC+, 8GB GDDR5, VR Ready, Dual BIOS, 3xDP HDMI DVI, AMD...
$124.97
in stock
2 new from $124.97
as of May 8, 2025 9:44 pm
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS Black Edition 1425MHz OC+, 8GB GDDR5, VR Ready, Dual BIOS, 3xDP HDMI DVI,...
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS Black Edition 1425MHz OC+, 8GB GDDR5, VR Ready, Dual BIOS, 3xDP HDMI DVI, AMD Graphics Card (RX-580P8DBD6)
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS Black Edition 1425MHz OC+, 8GB GDDR5, VR Ready, Dual BIOS, 3xDP HDMI DVI,...
$248.95
in stock
3 new from $238.00
3 used from $146.37
as of May 8, 2025 9:44 pm
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS XXX Edition 1386MHz OC+ 8GB GDDR5 VR Ready Dual BIOS 3xDP HDMI DVI AMD...
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS XXX Edition 1386MHz OC+ 8GB GDDR5 VR Ready Dual BIOS 3xDP HDMI DVI AMD Graphics Card (RX-580P8DFDA)
XFX Radeon RX 580 GTS XXX Edition 1386MHz OC+ 8GB GDDR5 VR Ready Dual BIOS 3xDP HDMI DVI AMD...
$208.00
in stock
2 new from $208.00
as of May 8, 2025 9:44 pm
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
Last updated on May 8, 2025 9:44 pm
Jump to section

4. A Closer Look

  • 1. Overview
  • 2. Specifications and Features
  • 3. Why now
  • 4. A Closer Look
  • 5. Testing Methodology
  • 6. Overclocking Results
  • 7. AC: Syndicate, Batman: AK, BF 4
  • 8. CoD: IW, Crysis 3, Far Cry Primal
  • 9. GTA V, Hitman, Rise of Tomb Raider
  • 10. Sleeping Dogs, TC: The Division, Witcher 3
  • 11. Strange Brigade, Battlefield 1, Shadow of the Tomb Raider
  • 12. CoD: WW2, Assassins Creed: O, Far Cry 5, BF 5
  • 13. TC: The Division 2, Far Cry: New Dawn
  • 14. 4K AC:O, 4K BF5, 4K CoD: WW2
  • 15. 4K Crysis 3, 4K Far Cry 5, 4K Rise of TR
  • 16. 4K Shadow of TR, 4K Strange Brigade, 4K Witcher 3
  • 17. 4K TC: The Division 2, 4K Far Cry: New Dawn
  • 18. Temperature, Noise, and Power Analysis
  • 19. Performance Summary and TL;DR
  • 20. Score Card and Summary
  • 21. Closing Thoughts

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 11

Where our review sample came to ‘gently used’ we cannot comment on this specific model’s shipping container or accessories. Instead all we will say is that XFX knows how to make shipping boxes that are pretty, attention getting, full of useful information, and robust. XFX has been doing this for many years so we highly doubt that the XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black is an exception to this rule.

ADVERTISEMENT

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 12

The XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black uses a very, very common form-factor for mainstream video-cards. This means two fans – not one or three, it means a dual slot thickness (not 2.5 or 3), and is slightly taller than the PCIe ‘full height’ standard. It is not MSI tall, but neither it is standard height. Instead it will be a touch taller than some and may cause issue in the occasional installation department, but mainly only if you have an odd-ball PC case. With that being said the XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black is bigger than the typical NVIDIA GTX 1660 and bigger than all but the most unusually proportioned NVIDIA GTX 1650. This is because it needs more surface area for its custom heatsink. After all, this is a 185 watt TDP video card, not some piddly 120 or 75 watt’er that can be cooled by a ball of tinfoil and mouse farts.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 13

Yes, the AMD Radeon RX 580 series did get a reputation for running hot. A well-earned reputation as the RX 580 ‘Polaris 20’ core is a refined, but most overclocked Polaris 10. Just as with manual overclocking when you push the voltages and frequencies higher than what a given design was originally intended for… heat and noise is going to be the byproduct. By modern standards, stating that 1400Mhz is ‘blazing fast’ for a core is ironic… but back when this core was first being designed it was blazingly fast.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 14

This increase in frequencies did necessitate a higher TDP. The TDP went from 150 (Polar 10 aka RX 480) to 185’ish (Polaris 20 aka RX 580) and also is why this card requires an 8-pin PCIe power connector… and not the typical 6-pin found on most 200 dollar cards. Needless to say, it will be drawing all 150 watts from this cable and then sucking down more via the PCIe x16 port itself. This is a lot of power for a $200 card to demand and is one of the largest weaknesses with this older design. So if power and heat output are of concern to you, a Radeon RX 580… any Radeon RX 580 is probably not right for your needs. Also of note, is the 8-pin power connector is recessed. This is less than optimal but was pretty common for its generation. As such a little bit more care is required to ensure that the PCIe power cable does not touch the heat pipe directly above it.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 15

With that said, the XFX “Double Dissipation” custom heatsink design does a rather good job at keeping temperatures and noise in check. The secret to its ability is the fact that it uses four copper heatpipes (that were rather cutting edge for its day in that they are ‘hybrid’ heatpipes which rely upon both liquid phase change and capillary action to increase efficiencies), a large nickel platted copper base plate, two aluminum cooling fin arrays, and two large 100mm fans (that actually stop spinning when thermal loads are low). By splitting the fin array into two smaller ‘zones’ a good portion of the two fan’s fresh air will not first go through the fin array, and rather will hit the secondary heat spreader located underneath it, and thus keep the various components like the RAM cool and happy. Equally important is XFX took the time to build the heatsink in such a manner that it also actively cools the VRM via the main heatsink itself. A lot of models did not take this step in the RX 500 series days… and the end results were seeming ‘cool cores’ with VRMs that were ready to pop from the heat (and did in some cases). This combination of cooling is why XFX were able to claim – and prove – that the VRMs would be 30-degrees Celsius cooler and the GDDR5 would be 20-degrees cooler than in typical (for its class) designs.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 16

For those interested in such things, this particular version of the XFX RX 580 series does not come with the easily replaceable fans. Instead it uses an ‘old school’ mounting setup that is not really meant to be swapped out by the owner. This is a good and a bad thing. On the negative side, when a fan goes you have to RMA the whole card. On the positive, there is lot less vibration noise from the fans. The removable fans were basically only held in place via plastic locking tabs… and as time went by did garner a bit of reputation for becoming ‘loose’ in their sockets. Which in turned increased noise. If you think this a feature you must have, if you look around the higher end XFX RX 580’s with this replaceable fan option they will only cost a few dollars more (about the same as a good NVIDIA GTX 1660).

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 17

XFX were one of the first to take ‘VRM buzz’ seriously so it should come as no surprise that the power delivery subsystem is full of rather advanced components. Parts like ‘ultra low noise’ XL inductors. Solid sate power delivery controller. 6+1 phase design to spread the load out nicely and keep everything cooler than usual. All these features have trickled down… but even today finding them all on 200 priced cards is not typical to say the least.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 18

Also extremely rare, for a 200 dollar class card, is the included dual BIOS option. Few include this potential (card) lifesaving feature. A feature that has gotten us out of more than one jam from a failed overclocking experiment over the years. As a side bonus, with dual BIOS you can not only ‘experiment’ more on overclocking, you can ‘find’ and install BIOS mods that would otherwise be insane to try out… as if it does go sideways you have the backup BIOS to get you out of a jam. Many a miner did just that when these cards were the new shiny of the marketplace.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 19

While we did skip over the overall aesthetics of this card, this is not because it is ugly, utilitarian… or even just ‘practical’. Instead it is a key part of what makes an XFX card instantly recognizable. In this instanced the XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black is not rectangular in shape. Instead it has an almost ‘wedge’ design to the PCB, heatsink, and top fascia, which combine to make one striking looking card.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 20

Mix in a nicely designed backplate (which while it does somewhat wrap up the top side of the PCB is mainly just here for protection and overall looks… not to act as a secondary heatspreader) and the end results are classic XFX. Classis elegance. Classic attention getting design. Classic unforgettable looks that beg to be used in a case with a large window. The only downside is the front of the card is encased in a shroud. A shroud that is not connected to the actual backplate. While there are long slits in this shroud. This inclusion is a bit ‘old school’ and while increases the aesthetics nicely, it also increases static pressure – as waste air cannot escape out the front of the card.

Of course, some modern buyers will be a bit put out by the lack of LEDs. No, this card will not light up like a Christmas tree. No there is no ‘advanced sync’ features. This card comes from the pre-LED on everything era… and we do miss it.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 21

As this is an older generation card one would expect an… ‘old school’ approach to monitor header options. The reality is it is more than what most ‘modern’ $200 cards come with. In grand total you will find one HDMI (2.0b), one DVI-D and three DisplayPort headers (DP 1.4). Equally impressive is there are no ‘mini’ versions here. So this is not an outdated options list to say the least.

XFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review 22

Overall, this card may soon to be two generations out of date but you would never know it from its build design or build quality. XFX really did overbuild these bad boys and it is a big reason why the Radeon RX 580 has become a cult classic in certain circles.

Jump to section

4. A Closer Look

  • 1. Overview
  • 2. Specifications and Features
  • 3. Why now
  • 4. A Closer Look
  • 5. Testing Methodology
  • 6. Overclocking Results
  • 7. AC: Syndicate, Batman: AK, BF 4
  • 8. CoD: IW, Crysis 3, Far Cry Primal
  • 9. GTA V, Hitman, Rise of Tomb Raider
  • 10. Sleeping Dogs, TC: The Division, Witcher 3
  • 11. Strange Brigade, Battlefield 1, Shadow of the Tomb Raider
  • 12. CoD: WW2, Assassins Creed: O, Far Cry 5, BF 5
  • 13. TC: The Division 2, Far Cry: New Dawn
  • 14. 4K AC:O, 4K BF5, 4K CoD: WW2
  • 15. 4K Crysis 3, 4K Far Cry 5, 4K Rise of TR
  • 16. 4K Shadow of TR, 4K Strange Brigade, 4K Witcher 3
  • 17. 4K TC: The Division 2, 4K Far Cry: New Dawn
  • 18. Temperature, Noise, and Power Analysis
  • 19. Performance Summary and TL;DR
  • 20. Score Card and Summary
  • 21. Closing Thoughts
Page 4 of 21
Previous 123456789101112131415161718192021 Next
Tags: 1650 vs RX 570AMDBest Value GPUGPUHD 580 vs 1660HD 580 vs GTX 1650RX vs GTXXFXXFX GTS Radeon RX 580 Black Review
ADVERTISEMENT
GaK_45

GaK_45

"Knowledgeable, opinionated and not afraid to ask the questions you can’t or won’t." GaK_45's combination of multiple industry certifications(MCSE, CCNA, various CompTIA, etc), and over twenty years' experience in the computer industry allows him to provide detailed analysis that is as trustworthy as it is practical.

Next Post
EVGA TORQ X10 Carbon Review

EVGA TORQ X10 Carbon Review

Leave Comment

Recommended.

Fallout 4 – Far Harbor

Fallout 4 – Far Harbor

July 29, 2016
Arctic Liquid Freezer II 360 Review

Arctic Liquid Freezer II 360 Review

ADVERTISEMENT

Trending.

Crucial Pro DDR5-5600 128GB Review

Crucial Pro DDR5-5600 128GB Review

Seagate Exos X18 Review

Seagate Exos X18 Review

Seagate IronWolf Pro 24TB Review

Seagate IronWolf Pro 24TB Review

Seagate Exos X24 Review

Seagate Exos X24 Review

MSI BE6500 WiFi 7 USB Review

MSI BE6500 WiFi 7 USB Review

Real Hardware Reviews

© 2013 - 2024 | Powered by Real Hardware Reviews

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Editorial & Disclosure Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Accessories
    • Processors (CPU)
    • GPU
    • Mobile
    • Games & Software
    • Systems
    • Cases
    • Tablet & Laptops
    • Ram
    • Storage
    • Motherboards
  • News
  • Off Topic
    • How To
    • Cryptocurrencies

© 2013 - 2024 | Powered by Real Hardware Reviews

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
x